The Growing Phenomenon of Coming to America to Give Birth
Coming to the U.S. solely to give birth and gain American citizenship for the newborn has been steadily increasing over the past decade. While the U.S. does not have a law granting automatic citizenship solely based on birthplace, under the 14th Amendment to the Constitution, which was passed in 1868, anyone born on U.S. soil is a U.S. citizen by birth. This has led many families from other countries, especially China and Russia, to travel to America for the purpose of having their babies born here and gain the citizenship perks.
Rise of the Birth Tourism Industry
As more people realized the benefits of U.S. citizenship through birthright, entire businesses sprang up to cater to birth tourism. Travel agencies started offering “maternity tours” or “birth tourism packages” to pregnant women from other countries. They organize travel itineraries, book accommodation near hospitals, help with legal paperwork and translation. In some cases, they even provide coaching on what to tell border control to avoid suspicion of planning to stay long term solely for childbirth. Some agencies openly advertise the citizenship aspect as a key benefit of their packages.
Controversy Over Loophole in Immigration Law
Critics argue that Birth Tourism exploits a loophole in the 14th Amendment by bringing foreigners into the country solely to game the system. They claim it threatens national security by granting citizenship to those who would not otherwise qualify for it through normal immigration processes. However, proponents counter that the 14th Amendment does not make exceptions based on parents’ motives. Altering birthright citizenship would also require a new amendment or federal law and is considered quite difficult. The debate has reignited calls to close the perceived birth tourism loophole but no concrete policy changes have been made so far.
Florida and California Most Popular Destinations
Due to their warm weather, availability of high-quality birthing facilities and networks of other immigrants, Florida and Southern California have emerged as top destinations for birth tourism. In particular, Miami, Los Angeles, San Francisco are very popular due to the proximity of international airports and large Chinese and Russian communities. It is estimated that thousands of babies are born every year in these states to foreign birth tourists. However, due to the covert nature of the practice, no official data is collected on how many foreign mothers travel specifically to give birth in the U.S.
Risks Involved with the Practice
While lucrative for the growing tourism industry that enables and profits from it, birth tourism also raises medical and legal risks. Pregnant women traveling long distances in the late stages can face complications especially if they do not get proper health checks pre-travel. There are also the risks of misleading or fraudulent information being provided by some agencies. On the legal front, if birth tourism births are discovered, it may affect the newborns’ ability to remain in the states in the future or sponsor family members for visas or green cards. Overall, this controversial multi-million dollar phenomenon continues to be a hotly debated aspect of the US immigration system.
Get more insights on Birth Tourism